The Shame Game

I’ve always had a strong sense of justice, and recently I came across a newly-published book that appealed to the side of me which likes to champion the underdog.

The book is called Fat-Talk Nation, and it was written by an anthropologist named Susan Greenhalgh. The subtitle of the book, published by Cornell University Press, is The Human Costs of America’s War on Fat.Cover, Fat-Talk Nation

The premise of the book caught my attention.

And, it got me thinking.

While it’s not news that Americans are fixated on weight, Dr. Greenhalgh believes we’ve reached a new level of hyper-awareness with the so-called “war on fat.”
Dr. Greenhalgh realized that while everyone was talking, admonishing, shaming, scolding, and essentially freaking out about how fat Americans have become, no one
had looked into the impact this relentless message was having on young people who are growing up during the war on fat era.

What she learned by listening to the stories of forty-five young people is that they were so anxious about their weight that it was wrecking their lives. We’ve reached the point where virtually no one feels good about their weight and body image.

What’s chilling is the stories themselves. Parents, aunts and uncles, school personnel – many people in authority seem oblivious to the impact of “fat shaming.”

And yet, according to Dr. Greenhalgh, tying a young person’s self-worth so closely to his or her weight is a recipe for disaster not just for the individual. It warps and interferes with the creation of normal, healthy relationships.

Those who are categorized “morbidly” obese do have an increased risk of death – and indeed we should be doing what we can to help them. But it’s pretty clear from Dr. Greenhalgh’s research that lecturing them does not get results.

Besides, there is a significant group of Americans, Dr. Greenhalgh points out, who fall into the category of “slightly obese” and who have a 5 percent LOWER risk of
early death.

In other words, the war on fat is not just misguided. It may be flat-out wrong.

Are there people who eat too much? Sure. Are there folks who eat unhealthy foods? Absolutely. Are there people who have a sedentary lifestyle? Of course.

But why is it acceptable, even encouraged, to ridicule them? To be cruel, and condescending?

It seems we live in an age that applauds the virtues of acceptance and tolerance, but none of that positive energy and generosity applies to the word “fat.”

I once knew a teenaged girl who was ridiculed (even by adults) for being overweight. What they did not know was that she’d had a kidney transplant, and the medications which kept her alive also made her gain weight. In fact, unwanted weight gain can be a side effect of a number of prescription medications. Should people be shamed into NOT taking medications which improve or even save their lives?

Here’s something else to ponder: There seems to be a weight-gain connection to endocrine-disrupting synthetic chemicals which have become part of American daily
life since the 1950s and 1960s. These chemicals exist in household products, food, water, and the air we breathe. What if it turns out that some people are more
susceptible to these chemicals than others, genetically speaking?

Kudos to Dr. Greenhalgh for her research, and for calling attention to another side to this important story.

Leave a comment

Filed under Stereotypes

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s